Case for Rooney Wearing Thin

England has not been kind to Louis Van Gaal.  The Dutchman, under such lofty expectations from the start, has failed to conjure any consistent form out of his expensive squad.  Angel Di Maria proves his worth with every appearance, Ander Herrera shines more and more, and Daley Blind ideally fits what United need.  

The results however, are not there.  Robin Van Persie has struggled with injury and poor form, Radamel Falcao has yet to open his account and improve his fitness, while Wayne Rooney is justifying his inclusion in the starting eleven less and less.  

10 years ago, Rooney was hailed by many as the next big thing in world football.  Rooney has been the face of the Three Lions for quite some time now, but that's not saying much considering the English' recent performances in major tournaments.  

Since he was named captain by Van Gaal, Rooney has struggled in his new role.  United are constantly losing focus for periods of time in matches, the Leicester outing being the perfect example.  

To his credit, Rooney was sprinting back to cover Marcos Rojo’s errant positioning in the second half on Sunday.  His reaction to the third goal however, was an indication of vulnerability and the Englishman feeling a lot of pressure.  

Rooney’s inch-perfect cross to Dean Hammond on the edge of David De Gea’s penalty area was what set up Cambiasso’s equalizer, and instead of shouldering the blame, Rooney erupted.  He is right to demand more out of his teammates, but blaming everyone seconds after shanking a clearance is no way to handle the captaincy.

It’s also evident that Juan Mata could be a better option beneath Falcao and Van Persie.  With the Colombian in the mix, Rooney is likely to find playing time in the playmaker role.  In theory, this would be ideal for the soon-to-be 29 year old.  He doesn’t have the explosive burst he once used to such great effect, but has always been an above-average passer.  

However, Rooney’s recent performances have made many question his appointment of leadership, let alone his inclusion in the side at all.  Mata, David Moyes’ 37 million pound signing, is riding the bench currently, and when put on the pitch is forced out on the wing.  

Mata is the better natural playmaker between the two, and if granted a central role would flourish.  Like Mesut Ozil, Mata is a 360 degree playmaker who prefers to have options from the middle.  His Spanish flair would suit Van Gaal’s style more than Rooney’s English heart.  With players like Di Maria, Herrera, and Falcao in the side, Manchester United are a changing club.  

The times are changing at Old Trafford; the Red Devils have their first foreign manager and a lineup now dominated by non English players.  Much has been said about Juan Mata’s poor defending and Rooney’s fastidiousness in pursuit of the ball.  Right now though, United need a change, and there is a perfectly good opportunity sitting on the bench.  

Rooney is over-applying himself and giving the impression that he is trying too hard, both in a leadership and a footballing sense.  Some time out of the starting eleven would benefit all parties involved at United.  Rooney would of course play, but not every game and not exclusively in the #10 role.  For now though, Juan Mata should be better utilized starting in the middle of the attack.  

Round Five: Studs & Duds

Studs

Frank Lampard, Manchester City: Don’t do a double take, that’s right, Frank Lampard plays for Manchester City now, at least for a few more months.  No one could have predicted this storyline a year ago, one which saw the former Chelsea man score the equalizer in a hotly contested match against the club he spent over a decade at.  His emotional goodbye to the traveling Chelsea supporters was a heartwarming sight, and his refusal to celebrate his goal showed his undeniable class.

The Leicester City Forwards: Leonardo Ulloa scored a booming header seconds after United extended their lead to 2-0, and later a spot kick after Jamie Vardy won the second of two penalties.  Vardy’s work-rate was inhuman on Sunday, while the eight million pounds Nigel Pearson paid for Ulloa is paying dividends.

Winston Reid, West Ham: Reid opened the scoring with a simple tap-in from James Tompkins’ flick off of an excellent Stewart Downing ball in.  Reid was constantly in the right place defensively, serving as a leader on the West Ham back line.  His goal was what started the momentum for the snatch-and-grab Hammers.

Ryan Bertrand, Southampton: Bertrand had expensive shoes to fill at the Saint Mary’s Stadium following Luke Shaw’s move to Manchester United, but the on-loan Chelsea man has proved his worth in the South.  Bertrand, billed as the successor to Ashley Cole a few years ago when he joined Stamford Bridge, is finally flashing the form we all expected of him back then. 

Mesut Ozil, Arsenal: “I don’t play to prove anything to anyone, I play for Arsenal.”  These were the words of Arsenal record signing Mesut Ozil in the morning papers, who silenced critics with a scintillating contribution at Villa Park on Monday.  Everyone points to the positional change as the reason for Ozil’s performance, but it’s nice to see the player confidently stand up for himself with both his words and his play on the pitch.  

Duds

Wilfried Bony, Swansea: Bony cost his side a chance to continue their strong start when he inexplicably earned himself two very bad yellow cards.  The second challenge on Maya Yoshida was unforgivable, and the suspension which follows the red card will further cost the Welsh club.  Credit to his teammates for keeping it close playing a man down for so long.   

Steven Gerrard, Liverpool: I called Gerrard’s display ‘spineless’ in my power rankings today, and after much contemplation, I concluded that this was not too harsh of a word to describe the former England captain.  Gerrard’s positioning as the only defensive midfielder doesn’t help him, but the one-club man’s influence is waning on Merseyside.  

Wayne Rooney, Manchester United: Rooney assisted on Di Maria’s mercurial tally in the first half, but otherwise struggled in the playmaking role for Manchester United.  The image of Wayne Rooney losing his head after Leicester tied the game won’t vacate twitter anytime soon, and neither will the speculations that Van Gaal chose the wrong man to captain his side.  

Tim Howard, Everton: It was unusual to see Howard make two such glaring errors.  First, Howard and Jon Stones had a collective brain fart, then the American missed his punch which led to Frazier Campbell’s goal.  As an American, I’m not used to seeing Howard make such awful mistakes.  

Liverpool Back Line: Between Manquillo, Lovren, Moreno, and Sakho, the Liverpool back line from Saturday’s horror show have one year of premier league experience.  Brendan Rodgers, known for his philosophies on the offensive side of the ball, may want to allocate more attention to his increasingly shaky back line led by a big-money signing who admitted to a lack in confidence early on.